The list below shows who the 2nd AL and NL Wild Cards teams would have been if 2 Wild Cards teams made the playoffs from 1995-2011, with notes of interest following.
Year AL NL
1995 LAA Hou
1996 Sea Wash (Mon)
1997 LAA LAD
1998 Tor SF
1999 Oak Cin
2000 Cle LAD
2001 Min SF
2002 Sea LAD
2003 Sea Hou
2004 Oak SF
2005 Cle Phil
2006 ChiW Phil
2007 Det SD
2008 NYY NYM
2009 Tex SF
2010 Bos SD
2011 Bos Atl
San Francisco would have made the playoffs 4 more times. The Dodgers and Mariners would have made it 3 more times. A full breakdown for the additional amount of times each team would have made the playoffs is below.
Toronto and Washington would have made the playoffs at least once. Toronto in 1998 and Washington in 1996 when the franchise was the Montreal Expos.
AL
3 times: Sea
2 times: Bos, Cle, LAA, Oak
1 time: ChiW, Det, Min, NYY, Tex, Tor
0 times: Balt, KC, TB
NL
4 times: SF
3 times: LAD
2 times: Hou, Phil, SD
1 time: Atl, Cin, NYM, Wash (as Mon)
0 times: Ari, ChiC, Col, Fla, Milw, Pitt, StL
Facebook
Twitter
